Licensed Under Creative Commons
|
About the Cover
August 15, 2008 - Bangor, Maine
On September 12, 2001, I was working as a television salesman.
My relationship with television has always been a reluctant one. Selling them in a thankless work environment only made me bitter towards the medium. Having to sell them the day after the first American tragedy of the 21st century was infuriating.
Television was washed over with remembrances, interviews with families looking for missing people. Some people hadn't been able to leave or enter Manhattan yet. There was still smoke in the air. I don't think I had yet heard the phrase "al-Qaeda," or the name of Osama Bin Laden.
United Airlines Flight 175 crashed into the World Trade Center, for me, approximately 126 times every seven minutes that day, news networks repeating the footage as I waited for people to buy televisions. (By the way, they did. One customer asked where everybody was, as if it was merely another slow business day. Most of the people in the store wore American flags. At the time, that gesture was still a show of community, only later would it evolve into a symbol of aggressive patriotism.
About a year later, haunted by that bombardment of imagery, I decided to throw myself into a dedicated act of remembering. The result is, in partial form, presented in the cover art of the book you're holding: Text blocks of the names of the Sept. 11 dead, colored to reflect the sequence of events which ended their lives.
It feels self-indulgent to say the process was harrowing. All I did was format a list of names into an image converter; I didn't worry if my girlfriend was stuck in the building or if a grandparent would be able to leave a nearby apartment. I just read and formatted every name that I could fit. An initial version of the project had names which served as links to Google search results. That process, designed to make these names human again instead of reducing them to television moments, was overwhelming.
When I put the piece online, I was reluctant. It was covered by The New York Times not based on any press release or promotional effort on my behalf, but by a posting to a mailing list asking people if this was OK or not. I was still uncertain when the paper interviewed me, in what ended up being the dubious highlight of press attention in my artistic career.
This, in itself, is problematic. Art about Sept. 11 is beyond any artist's ability to control. I was charged with being lazy and opportunistic, praised and criticized for capturing a patriotic zeitgeist. I've taken the piece offline and put it back up multiple times since the launch of the Iraq war. To me, those images are, on the one hand, a simple attempt to connect to this tragedy on a human level ˆ the names layer ˆ but they are also, inevitably, the image that launched the War on Terror, the invasion of Iraq, and the politics of fear. As such, I have a bipolar reaction to what the piece revealed, in the face of my own artistic and political naiveté: Humanizing the event doesn't stop us from politicizing it.
In fact, it contributes to the power of the images themselves as a tool of fear. It plays with the emotions of survivors, even those who merely survived watching it on television. It intensifies the images to a saddening extent, triggers a flight-or-flight response, swoops in with giant military might and gathers our will into wars. This statement, itself, is another side of the hypocrisy of humanization: I'm using it for political purposes, too.
This brings us to the flip book. I am drawn to the flipbook because it is not political. It simply says what has needed to be said: This is what happened. There is the smooth satisfaction of undoing the event by flipping backward, but always the temptation to make it happen again, in the way books inevitably turn forward. I am sure this book will provoke some angry reactions. It ought to. Some people don't need to be told that this event simply happened: it has hit them personally, and they have a right to whatever reaction they want.
The rest of us, however, need to move out of a collective haze. Most of us have. The end of the Bush Administration brings the end of the Sept. 11 decade. The flipbook comes just in time: Put it in your pocket. Leave it there, like car keys. But stop forcing it to mean anything outside of what it was: a senseless day of violence that we have more than made up for abroad.
There was a kind of beauty to that day, a reminder of the limited scope and fragility of our mortality, made almost comfortable by our collective confrontation. I don't think we lived up to the aftermath of that confrontation, and wallowing in Sept. 11 nostalgia ˆ which we have turned into two wars and long airport queues ˆ is not going to help anyone.
Summary, care of Foucault:
"All of this beauty of old times is an effect of and not a reason for nostalgia. I know very well that it is our own invention. But it's quite good to have this kind of nostalgia, just as it's good to have a good relationship with your own childhood if you have children. It's a good thing to have nostalgia toward some periods on the condition that it's a way to have a thoughtful and positive relation to your own present. But if nostalgia is a reason to be aggressive and uncomprehending toward the present, it has to be excluded." |
Eryk Salvaggio |
|
|
Name |
Date |
Location |
Title |
Scott Bl8ke |
September 17, 2008 |
Omaha, Nebraska |
Introduction |
1. Sarah Baker |
March 12, 2006 |
Omaha, Nebraska |
The very first essay |
2. Sean Smith |
May 10, 2006 |
Toronto, Canada |
Tactical application of slowness |
3. Mike Fischer |
May 17, 2006 |
Racine, Wisconsin |
My birthday is September 11 |
4. Pat Riot |
May 23, 2006 |
Los Angeles, California |
9-11 FLIP OUT |
5. Julian Miller |
May 31, 2006 |
New York, New York |
Desperate grab for attention |
6. Scott Grant |
June 5, 2006 |
Bristol, United Kingdom |
I wished I didn't own a television |
7. Daniel Clark |
June 6, 2006 |
Henderson, Nevada |
Media Monotony |
8. Damon Lawner |
June 10, 2006 |
Los Angeles, California |
Concise yet massive story |
9. Natalie Conforti |
June 12, 2006 |
San Francisco, California |
American student in Italy |
10. K Torpy |
June 13, 2006 |
Omaha, Nebraska |
Incomprehensible accessible |
11. Pierre Ernest |
June 18, 2006 |
Borsbeek, Belgium |
I also was born on Sept. 11th |
12. Timothy Schaffert |
June 18, 2006 |
Omaha, Nebraska |
Lesson in commerce and tragedy |
13. Chris Fischer |
June 18, 2006 |
Landisville, Pennsylvania |
i could give a fuck less |
14. Aaron Norhanian |
June 19, 2006 |
Brooklyn, New York |
Hold the moment in my hand |
15. Anonymous |
June 19, 2006 |
Anonymous. |
i think that Bush planned it |
16. Steve Chudomelka |
June 19, 2006 |
Omaha, Nebraska |
Caught in the moment again |
17. Adam Arsenault |
June 19, 2006 |
Prince Edward Island, Canada |
Respecting each other's visions |
18. Pierre-François Maquaire |
June 19, 2006 |
Paris, France |
I collect folioscopes |
19. Kim Lyvang |
June 20, 2006 |
Ontario, Canada |
My life is now richer |
20. Alexis Turner |
June 20, 2006 |
Portland, Oregon |
Listen to *me* |
21. Patrick Hughes |
June 21, 2006 |
Gainesville, Florida |
I would not like a 9-11 flipbook |
22. Philippe Dubost |
June 26, 2006 |
Chamalières, France |
Sensational effects of this game |
23. Jean-Pierre Becker |
June 27, 2006 |
Paris, France |
I could smile about your question |
24. Jayne Sonshine |
June 28, 2006 |
Twp. of Washington, New Jersey |
Hold a piece of history |
25. Tabitha Straws |
June 28, 2006 |
Seattle, Washington |
Selfish American |
26. K. Verbonus |
June 28, 2006 |
Steilacoom, Washington |
Everyone wants to be right |
27. Jo Bryan |
June 28, 2006 |
Cambs, United Kingdom |
Another frantic day |
28. Hayley Gardiner |
June 28, 2006 |
Northampton, United Kingdom |
Not just about the victims |
29. David Vogt |
June 28, 2006 |
Rockford, Illinois |
Feelings and emotions of others |
30. Nick Jugovics |
June 28, 2006 |
Paxton, Illinois |
Made from suffering |
31. Lennaert Bosch |
June 28, 2006 |
Cuijk, The Netherlands |
Ten and a half year old |
32. Anonymous |
June 29, 2006 |
Anonymous |
Trivializing those events |
33. David Pitman |
July 1, 2006 |
South Wales, United Kingdom |
Slap in the face |
34. Tracy Cowell |
July 1, 2006 |
Somerset, United Kingdom |
Agree with it or not |
35. Candy VanOcker |
July 1, 2006 |
Springville, New York |
This happened to everyone |
36. Fadel Haowat |
July 1, 2006 |
Chicago, Illinois |
What the news can do |
37. Daniel Sahagian |
July 1, 2006 |
North Arlington, New Jersey |
Light against Hate and Ignorance |
38. Sam Brobvision |
July 1, 2006 |
Nottingham, United Kingdom |
Little effect on my life |
39. Cain Radford |
July 1, 2006 |
Broken Hill, Australia |
Through tragedy life goes on |
40. Susan Rabka |
July 1, 2006 |
Johannesburg, South Africa |
I might as well have been there |
41. Anonymous |
July 1, 2006 |
San Francisco, California |
Arbiter of the act |
42. Julie Gormly |
July 2, 2006 |
Brisbane, Australia |
Uncomfortable sharing |
43. Nicola Dingle |
July 2, 2006 |
Somerset, United Kingdom |
Seize the day |
44. Tarryn Bow |
July 3, 2006 |
Broken Hill, Australia |
Far more shocking |
45. Ricardo dC Russo |
July 3, 2006 |
Manaus, Brazil |
World is full of lost words |
46. Pascal Fouché |
July 4, 2006 |
Paris, France |
How people can see it |
47. Anthony Mack |
July 4, 2006 |
Lacey, Washington |
ALL humans strive for freedom |
48. Teri Jenkins |
July 6, 2006 |
Ontario, Canada |
Deepest sympathies |
49. Alexandre Noyer |
July 6, 2006 |
Annecy, France |
Internationnal langage |
50. Yolanda Yuyu |
July 6, 2006 |
Chengdu, China |
It tell us to remember something |
51. Craig Park |
July 7, 2006 |
Rocky Mount, North Carolina |
Are we better for our learning |
52. Kell Black |
July 11, 2006 |
Clarksville, Tennessee |
Small matchbox diorama |
53. Anonymous |
July 12, 2006 |
United States |
Sophisticated visual humor |
54. Lauren De Luca |
July 12, 2006 |
New York, New York |
Less than a mile from the Towers |
55. Nanette Allen |
July 12, 2006 |
Las Vegas, Nevada |
Intimate translations |
56. Manfred Reichert |
July 21, 2006 |
Visselhoevede, Germany |
Flash animation |
57. B Rousse |
July 22, 2006 |
Paris, France |
It deserves our irreverence |
58. Charlotta Bjorkskog |
July 22, 2006 |
Kokkola, Finland |
Of course you gain on it |
59. Stuart and Tara |
July 24, 2006 |
Brooklyn, New York |
Better view on the TV |
Eryk Salvaggio |
August 15, 2008 |
Bangor, Maine |
About the Cover |
60. Dave Schneider |
January 29, 2007 |
Chicago, Illinois |
Remind me of "real" pain |
61. Dan Keane |
January 30, 2007 |
Bloomfield, New Jersey |
what the fuck was the 'message'? |
62. Thomas Hill |
February 6, 2007 |
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma |
perception is reality |
63. Robert Fischer |
March 29, 2007 |
Houma, Louisiana |
the defining moment |
64. Frank J Perrotta |
December 5, 2007 |
Sharon, Pennsylvania |
9-11 Flip Book Manipulations |
65. Matthew Lahey |
January 7, 2008 |
Los Angeles, Califronia |
On A Flipbook |
66. Kristin Heikel |
March 16, 2008 |
Omaha, Nebraska |
Reporting and Voyeurism |
67. Aibyouka Kun |
September 29, 2008 |
Westmont, New Jersey |
The First IM Chat |
68. Bobby Ryan |
November 4, 2008 |
North Cape May, New Jersey |
Patriotic Work of Art |
69. Trevon Watson |
February 3, 2009 |
Guyton, Georgia |
War On Terror is Fading Away |
70. Adrian Davis |
February 17, 2009 |
Fort Bragg, North Carolina |
Something you care about |
71. Dear |
December 26, 2008 |
Portland, Oregon |
Second IM Chat |
72. James King |
May 4, 2009 |
Glasgow, Scotland |
The world will never be the same |
73. Beáta Istvánko |
October 27, 2009 |
Budakalász, Hungary |
Opinion of the audience |
74. Alex Klehfoth |
June 1, 2009 |
Lexington, Kentucky |
Twin Tower Pinata |
75. Wolfgang Skodd |
May 5, 2010 |
Dortmund, Germany |
Agents & Provocateurs |
76. Michiko Tanaka |
August 2, 2010 |
Seattle, Washington |
Over and over |
77. DJ Tilley |
January 7, 2011 |
Reno, Nevada |
Wandering around the playground |
78. Benjamin Goggin |
January 8, 2011 |
Portland, Oregon |
Tornadoes to terrorism |
79. Tom Eubank |
January 8, 2011 |
New York City, New York |
Top floor of 95 Christopher Street |
80. Ian |
January 8, 2011 |
Oakland, California |
Stir things up |
81. Anonymous |
February 24, 2011 |
Anonymous |
Inconsiderate and offensive |
82. Amanda Marsico |
March 3, 2011 |
District of Columbia, USA |
Thank you for making me think |
83. Anonymous |
April 18, 2011 |
Anchorage, Alaska |
This isint a joke |
84. Jessica Schwartz |
April 27, 2011 |
USA |
Who is the work for? |
85. Dr. Kevin Dann |
May 19, 2011 |
Brooklyn, New York |
Thanks Art Spiegelmann |
86. TheBigBoss |
May 26, 2011 |
Nairobi, Kenya |
Le Chêne et le Roseau |
87. Stephania |
June 27, 2011 |
USA |
More Real Than Reality |
88. Anonymous |
July 11, 2011 |
Brooklyn, New York |
Weak and Irresponsible |
89. Renee Nied |
August 4, 2011 |
Cobleskill, New York |
Pick Up Tomorrow |
90. Elliott Burris |
September 2, 2011 |
Saint Joseph, Missouri |
I was only 3 |
91. Sheila Zachariae |
September 9, 2011 |
Omaha, Nebraska |
Protecting the people from themselves |
92. Wendy Parker |
November 6, 2011 |
Leicester, United Kingdom |
Interesting Yet Horrifying |
93. Aidan Hicks |
March 12, 2012 |
Aurora, Colorado |
Quite Young on September 11 |
94. Patrick McCarthy |
April 17, 2012 |
Chicago, Illinois |
Propaganda Attack |
95. Billy |
October 12, 2012 |
Sandia Park, New Mexico |
Bling Review 41 |
96. Gabriella Cutrone |
June 25, 2013 |
Brooklyn, New York |
Inspired and Upset |
97. BSG |
October 31, 2013 |
Portland, Oregon |
Images Detach From Emotions |
98. Wilfredo Raguro |
July 28, 2016 |
Irving, Texas |
Looking Back Now |
|
|
Return to Flipbooks |
|